We promised to answer your questions publicly – we start withe first question today.
#1
Is it possible to formulate a valid but not antisemitic critique of Israel’s siege of Gaza as an unjustified act of collective punishment that necessitates an immediate and permanent ceasefire?
This question was kindly submitted by J. and concerned ohter people, too. Thank you.
Of course, it is possible to criticize Israel’s military actions in Gaza without reproducing antisemitism or using antisemitic tropes.
The campaign of the relatives and supporters of the hostages for example criticized the Israeli government and their (war) strategy. They put pressure on them to find a solution for a ceasefire. Hundreds of thousands of Israelis had been protesting against their government before 7/10.
Unfortunately, the second part of your question bears questionable assumptions. The war in Gaza is not ‚unjustified‘: Hamas declared war on Israel – and Hamas currently rules Gaza. Hamas is waging war on its people: by committing atrocities like the attack on the 7.10 (another on the 30.11. in Jerusalem) as well as continuously fighting is „collectively sacrificing“ them.
Israel is aiming to destroy Hamas, not the Palestinians. The devastating death toll of Palestinian civilians is due to the horrible tactics of Hamas and – in general – to the brutal logic of war. This, granted under international law, allows striking military targets despite possible „civilian collateral damage“. And yes, war is always horrible and should end and we are deeply unhappy to see this unfolding. But at the same time, we do not see people condemning e.g. Ukraine for its self-defence in the same way. These are certainly double standards. Painting a picture of Israel as a blood-thirsty terror state (as some people, whose comments also reached us, do) opens a variety of links to antisemitic thinking and therefore violence against Jews all over the world.
We supported and still support a call for a ceasefire given these conditions and aims (just to clarify: adresses both opponents):
Hamas to immediately and unconditionally release all hostages
Hamas to unconditionally surrender
Until this happens we are convinced that Israel has the right to self-defense and fight Hamas.
Without Hamas being stripped of control of Gaza there isn’t even the slightest chance of peace in the Middle East and the suffering of the Palestinians will continue endlessly.
We want to support Palestinian and Israeli voices that want true and long-lasting peace. This peace can only be built on trust. How this trust can be established after the attack on the 7th of Oct. and this war provoked by Hamas is the question.
It can only be answered by democratic forces and Islamists like Hamas are anything but.